UFT Hits Airwaves With Anti-Cuomo Ad

From the Morning Memo:

The United Federation of Teachers, the NYC-based teachers union, has launched a new ad this morning that accuses Cuomo of playing politics with public schools and criticizes the education reform agenda he pushed during the budget battle.

The 30-second ad is part of a multimillion-dollar statewide campaign that kicks off in the NYC metro area today, and will hit the rest of the state tomorrow, according to a UFT press release.

It will run on major broadcast and cable news programs, the union said, as well as on some of television’s most popular shows including: “Scandal,” the finale of “The Americans,” “American Crime,” “The Blacklist,” “Mad Men,” “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart,” and Major League Baseball – both the Yankees and the Mets.

The ad appears to be in response to a pro-Cuomo spot that has been running for several weeks, thanking the governor for his education reforms. That ad was paid for by the pro-charter organization Students First.

It’s interesting that the UFT made this move, especially since the union was blamed for perhaps declaring victory in the budget battle a little too soon, angering Cuomo and spurring him to push harder in the eleventh hour for reform measures the unions – and many Democratic lawmakers – really didn’t like.

The UFT was noticeably quiet when the statewide teachers union, NYSUT, launched its push to get parents to opt their kids out of standardized tests in an effort to undermine the teacher evaluation system.

And some upstate Assembly Democrats who are under fire from NYSUT have quietly complained that the UFT let downstate members off the hook when it came to voting “yes” on the education portion of the budget.

Here’s the script for the UFT’s ad, which was produced by Shorr Johnson Magnus Strategic Media:

“For months Andrew Cuomo attacked teachers and public schools. Now, with his support at record lows, so-called education reformers and their billionaire backers are running TV ads trying to rewrite history. But we know the truth.

“Cuomo wants to pile on high stakes testing, privatize classrooms, and divert money away from public schools by giving huge tax breaks to the wealthy.”

“Governor, New Yorkers agree: Put politics aside and put our kids first.”

Clinton’s Gain Is Maloney’s Loss

From the Morning Memo:

As Hillary Clinton continues to staff up her 2016 campaign operation across the country, she has poached a top aide of a New York congressman who once worked for her husband in the White House.

Clinton has tapped Stephanie Formas to serve as her communications director in South Carolina. Formas, a Texas native, is currently the deputy chief of staff to Rep. Sean Patrick Maloney, who was former President Clinton’s senior West Wing adviser and White House staff secretary.

Maloney, a Democrat, recently won re-election to a second two-year term, defeating the Republican he ousted from the House in 2012, former Rep. Nan Hayworth.

The congressman routinely played up his Clinton ties during his campaigns, and received an in-person boost from the former secretary of state/US senator/first lady shortly before the general election last year.

Here and Now

Gov. Andrew Cuomo is due back from Cuba today. He’s scheduled to be the guest speaker at the Food Bank for NYC’s 13th Annual Can Do Awards Dinner, where the publishing company of his girlfriend, Food Network star Sandra Lee, is among the honorees.

The Legislature returns to work after a nearly three-week spring break, kicking off the post-budget session.

It was expected to be a busy time, given how many policy issues were pushed out of the budget to be dealt with later. But the US attorney’s investigation into Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos and his son, Adam, could put a damper on things in a big way, giving lawmakers the incentive (on that side of the Capitol, anyway) to mark time without getting much done until the session ends in June.

There are some big ticket items that need to be dealt with. Both the NYC rent laws and mayoral control of the NYC schools “sunset” in June. But the Senate Republicans didn’t have much interest in the first place in doing anything to assist NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio, who tried unsuccessfully to help the Democrats re-take the majority last fall.

And there’s very little the GOP conference wants or needs in terms of horse trading possibilities, with the exception of the Education Investment Tax Credit and raising the charter cap.

The Democrats, on the other hand, want and need quite a bit, including the aforementioned NYC issues, another increase in the minimum wage, the DREAM Act, and criminal justice reform – just to name a few.

Also happening today…

NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio will attend an event hosted by the Campaign for One New York. This event will be closed press.

At 8:15 a.m., Department of Financial Services superintendent Ben Lawsky participates in Q&A at Wall Street Journal’s newsmaker’s forum, Le Parker Meridien, 119 W. 56th St., Manhattan.

From 9 a.m. to noon, the state’s Human Rights Commissioner Helen Diane Foster, and state Department of Homes and Community Renewal’s Tenant Protection Unit Deputy Commissioner Richard White, speak during the introduction of a public education campaign about housing discrimination regulations; art gallery, second floor, Adam Clayton Powell Jr. State Office Building, 163 W. 125th St., Manhattan.

At 9:30 a.m., Brooklyn Borough President Eric L. Adams, joined by community and government officials and senior citizens, introduces his pedestrian safety initiative titled “Connecting Residents on Safer Streets Brooklyn” or “CROSS Brooklyn”; Amico Senior Citizens Center, 5901 13th Ave., Brooklyn.

At 10 a.m., to publicize the completion of a $25 million project intended to reduce Grand Central Terminal’s energy costs and usage, NYPA President and CEO Gil Quiniones and MTA Chairman and CEO Thomas Prendergast hold a news conference and tour, coinciding with the Wednesday, April 22, observance of Earth Day; near the clock, main concourse, Park Avenue and 42nd Street, Manhattan.

At 11 a.m., the New York State Nurses Association holds a rally, West Capitol Park, Albany.

Also at 11 a.m., FASNY President Robert McConville and local firefighters announce the fifth annual RecruitNY statewide firefighter recruitment initiative, Baldswinsville Volunteer Fire Department Station One, 7911 Crego Rd., Baldswinsville.

At 11:45 a.m., Assemblywoman Aileen Gunther, representatives from the Gay Men’s Health Crisis and other patient advocates hold a news conference on meningitis vaccinations, Room 130, Legislative Office Building, 198 State St., Albany.

At 1 p.m., NYC Council members Jumaane Williams and Helen Rosenthal hold a joint oversight hearing on de Blasio’s housing plan, City Hall chambers, Manhattan.

At 2 p.m., the Assembly is in session, Assembly chamber, Capitol, Albany.

At 3 p.m., the Senate is in session, Senate chamber, Capitol, Albany.

At 6 p.m., Cuomo speaks at the Food Bank for New York City’s annual Can Do awards dinner, Cipriani Wall Street, 55 Wall St., Manhattan.

At 6:30 p.m., Staten Island DA and NY-11 GOP candidate Dan Donovan and Safe Horizon officials sponsor a 21st annual “Staten Island Crime Victims’ Candlelight Vigil,” marking the observance of “National Crime Victims’ Rights Week” from Sunday through Saturday, April 19 to 25; SIPP Auditorium, Richmond University Medical Center, 355 Bard Ave., Staten Island.


Gov. Andrew Cuomo remained optimistic about the opportunities for doing business with Cuba, despite the many obvious barriers that were on display during his whirlwind trade mission there.

Cuomo reiterated his goal was to generate “momentum” to help federal officials roll back legal impediments and grant some licenses – including one that would let JetBlue begin regular service – as soon as possible.

While in Cuba, Cuomo indulged his gearhead side, marveling at a 1956 Chevrolet Bel Air that had a Toyota engine inside. He was also presented by the country’s trade minister with what he said was his first Cuban cigar.

“Isolation has not worked,” Cuomo said of the US strategy for dealing with Cuba. “We have had 50 years of isolation and it has not worked. Engagement and full relationships is the best way on the issues that we agree with and the issues that we disagree with.”

After several years in which teachers’ unions have been hammered on the issue of tenure, have lost collective bargaining rights in some states and have seen their evaluations increasingly tied to student scores, they have begun, with some success, to reassert themselves using a bread-and-butter issue: the annual tests given to elementary and middle school students in every state.

The UFT released a new TV ad today to “set the record straight” on Cuomo’s education agenda, accusing him of playing politics with public schools.

More >


A NYT investigation found Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie benefitted from his mother’s embezzling, failing to sell an apartment purchased with ill-gotten gains when directed by a judge, and then profitting when he finally did so.

The schedule for Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s 25-hour trade mission to Cuba includes a “working lunch” with Rodrigo Malmierca Diaz, Cuba’s Minister of Trade and Foreign Investments, and a meeting with the country’s first vice president, Miguel Diaz-Canel.

The governor’s Flickr page has some photos of his trip.

Onondaga County Republican Committee Chairman Tom Dadey was among Republicans blasting Cuomo’s trip to Cuba, calling it shortsighted and ill-advised.

Republican Assemblywoman Nicole Malliotakis, a Staten Islander whose mother is a Cuban exile, said any efforts to normalize relations must be accompanied by significant concessions from the Castro regime.

Former Spring Valley Mayor Noramie Jasmin was found guilty of selling her vote for a 50-percent ownership in a community center-catering hall offered by a Monsey developer working as an undercover FBI operative.

Was former Gov. David Paterson’s criticism of US Attorney Preet Bharara planted, encouraged or otherwise influenced by Cuomo?

New York City’s subway system carried 1.75 billion customers last year, as ridership grew by the highest annual amount in more than 65 years, according to new figures released by the MTA.

Supporting District Attorney Daniel Donovan’s bid for Congress and his handling of the explosive Eric Garner case, former Mayor Rudy Giuliani will host a fundraiser for the Republican candidate next weekend.

At least 14 former state lawmakers are currently collecting a state pension despite being convicted of a crime.

Kentucky Sen. Rand Paul is soliciting information regarding the Clinton Foundation’s acceptance of contributions from foreign governments in his latest move to cast doubt on the former secretary of state’s candidacy.

The New York Times, The Washington Post and Fox News have made exclusive agreements with a conservative author for early access to his opposition research on Clinton – a move that has confounded members of her campaign and some reporters.

Assemblywoman Margaret Markey wants Pope Francis to meet with survivors of sexual abuse when he visits New York in September.

Republican Assemblyman Anthony Palumbo has told county Republican leaders he is taking a “hard look” at challenging Democratic County Executive Steve Bellone this fall and will make a final decision by next week.

The Shooters Committee on Political Education wrote an open letter to Senate Republicans, accusing senators of reneging on their pledge to not support a budget that includes SAFE Act funding.

Declaring traffic tie-ups of up to three hours “unacceptable,” Sen. Chuck Schumer vowed to wield his “clout” to help fund a $64 million proposal for widening the U.S. plaza at the Lewiston-Queenston Bridge.

Two LLCs connected to Leonard Litwin’s Glenwood Management donated a total of $5,000 to state Assembly candidate Shirley Paterson, who is running for former Assemblyman Karim Camara’s seat and is backed by the powerful Brooklyn Democratic Party.

The fight against mixed martial arts has escalated, with a group of prominent New York Jewish leaders saying that legalizing the controversial sport could benefit a major anti-Israel force.

Here are this year’s Pulitzer Prize winners, which include Buffalo News cartoonist Adam Zyglis, who won for editorial cartooning.

POLITICO publisher Robert Allbritton has set a goal of tripling the size of the company in four years, POLITICO co-founders Jim VandeHei and John Harris said in a staff memo today.

A Saranac Lake teacher finished a 150-mile protest march to the state Capitol today.

New York Democrats Fundraise Off Walker Fundraiser

The New York Democratic state committee on Monday blasted a fundraiser being held in Manhattan today for Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker — and sought to raise some money themselves.

Walker, a likely Republican candidate for president, is common fodder for liberals after he gained national prominence for his fights with labor unions in his state and his support from Charles and David Koch.

“He is an enemy of hard-working American families, and his values are NOT New York values. It’s that simple,” wrote the party’s new executive director Basil Smikle. “He stands against the rights of workers in his home state and everywhere. Although everyone is welcome here in New York, his wrongheaded, ultra-conservative policies are not.”

Walker has pursued tough policies against organized labor.

In New York, Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo has a decidedly mixed record with labor unions as well. Cuomo has bolstered support among private-sector unions that represent builders, construction and health-care interests like 1199 SEIU as well as the Hotel Trades Council.

However, Cuomo was not endorsed by the AFL-CIO’s state chapter. He remains at odds with the statewide teachers union, NYSUT, over his education policies included in the state budget that seek to weaken tenure.

At the same time, Cuomo angered rank-and-file public employees at the Civil Service Employees Association and the Public Employees Federation for pushing less generous labor contracts that expire or have expired this year.

Cuomo in 2013 also pushed through a new, less generous pension level, Tier Six.

Still, Cuomo has not pursued labor measures to the extent that Walker has, such as right-to-work laws.

Good-Government Groups: Don’t Stock Review Panel With ‘Usual Suspects’

A coalition of good-government groups on Monday urged Gov. Andrew Cuomo and legislative leaders to not stock a review commission charged with reporting on the workings of the ethics regulators with the “usual suspects” who will rubberstamp any findings.

In a letter to Cuomo and Senate and Assembly leaders, the groups write that the review panel should be conducted in a transparent process and put the public interest first in conducting its work.

“In making these recommendations, we urge you to go beyond the “usual suspects” that are often appointed on public commissions, and ask that the appointees publicly pledge to put the interests of the public ahead of their appointing authorities,” the groups write. “Moreover, the review panel’s work must be conducted as openly as possible in order to help build public support for whatever measures the panel recommends.”

The panel would review the workings of both the Legislative Ethics Commission and the Joint Commission on Public Ethics. The commission would be charged with reviewing how effective those institutions are and what changes can be made.

The good-government groups see room for improvement.

“Even when compared to the rest of the nation, New York’s ethics enforcement ranks poorly: In a 2012 comparison of state ethics laws, New York’s ethics enforcement received a grade of ‘F,'” the groups wrote.

Ideal commission members would be those who have not been lobbying or working for a lobbying shop for the last five years, have been involved in political consulting in the last five years or have held elected office during that time.

The review commission was actually supposed to be in place in 2013, with a report due more than a year ago. The state budget agreement last month included new deadlines of forming the panel by May 1, with an eye toward releasing a report by Nov. 1.

Merged Release and Letter Review Panel by Nick Reisman

Funke Bill Would Repeal The Yacht And Airplane Tax Break

When it comes to the tax breaks for boats and aircraft in the state budget, Rochester-area Republican Sen. Rich Funke appears to be having some buyer’s remorse.

Funke on Monday announced he was introducing a bill that would repeal the tax break, which exempts sales tax when it comes to the purchase of boats and aircraft of more than $230,000.

In a legislative memorandum attached to the bill, Funke notes sales tax breaks can serve a justifiable purpose when contributing to a greater societal good, such as clean energy.

“Sales tax exemptions should not be used however, to provide benefits to a very few New Yorkers who can afford a particular product, while producing no discernible job creation benefit,” the bill memo states. “The sales tax exemption for certain yachts and planes is bad public policy. Tax reductions should be broad based and above-all they should provide benefits to average
hard working New Yorkers.”

Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos has defended the tax break, which he said could help generate jobs and make New York more competitive with states like Florida.

At the same time, the tax break is seen as a potential boon to boat builders and airplane manufacturers, as well as those who operate marinas and airports around the state.

The measure is seen as considerably bad optics as lawmakers did not take up a minimum wage increase in this year’s budget — a fact that hasn’t escape liberal critics who had pushed for the wage hike.

Senate Democrats, too, noted that Funke backed the budget as whole before calling for a repeal of the sales tax break.

“I’m not sure who Senator Funke thinks he is fooling,” Senate Democratic spokesman Mike Murphy said. “Less than a month ago he voted for this outrageous tax break rather than a minimum wage increase and now he is trying to fool the voters into thinking he wants to repeal it. In four short months Funke has proven he will say one thing in his district and then once in Albany he will go along with his Republican colleagues no matter how much it hurts the people of New York.”

Updated: Jesse Sleezer, a spokesman for Funke, responded to the criticism from Senate Democrats.

“Every single Democrat Senator had the opportunity to take-on the Yacht Tax Break after the Budget and only Senator Funke stepped to the plate. Talk is cheap, especially when it’s hot air, so while partisan Democrats play political games in Albany, Senator Funke will be busy standing up for Monroe and Ontario counties.”

2015 Yacht Tax Break Repeal Memo by Nick Reisman

Cuomo: Isolation Of Cuba Is Not Working

Gov. Andrew Cuomo on Monday defended his trade mission to Cuba, telling reporters on a plane ride there that decades of isolation haven’t moved the country toward improvement on both economics and human rights.

“After 50 years of isolation with no change, maybe you start to think we should go to plan B,” Cuomo said.

The trip is part of a suite of trade missions Cuomo plans in the coming months, with trips being set for countries like Italy, China and Mexico later on.

Cuomo’s trip is meant to expand business opportunities for New York-based companies, though he reiterated today that he hopes the Communist-led country begins to change its posture on human rights issues.

“There is no doubt that Cuba has more progress to make on human rights,” Cuomo said. “There is no doubt that Cuba has progress to make on LGBT rights and relationships.”

But for the most part, Cuomo does not expect human rights discussions to dominate the 24-hour trip to the country.

“When it comes up and its appropriate, we will,” he said when asked if he will initiate talk on human rights with Cuban leaders. “The business people on this plane are not diplomats. They’re here to talk about business.”

Cuomo had previously insisted the trip would focus strictly on business and expanding New York companies into the new Cuban market.

Cuomo today is due to meet with Rodrigo Malmierca Díaz, the Cuban minister of trade and foreign investments. In addition, he is expected to hold a private meeting with First Vice President Miguel Diaz-Canel.

Cuomo is traveling with a contingent of New York business representatives, including MasterCard, Jet Blue and Chobani.

The governor said he expects that as the U.S. begins to normalize relations with Cuba, the emerging market will be a fast one to open.

“I have no doubt that Cuba is going to be an exciting market to be in for business,” Cuomo said, adding, “I believe the unfolding of the market will happen in a shorter period of time than a longer period of time.”

Cuomo noted that his late father, former Gov. Mario Cuomo, called for an end to the embargo of Cuba in 1996.

“Isolation is not working,” Cuomo said. “It’s not having the desired effect. Go to plan B.”

Paterson: Preet’s Great, But…

Former Gov. David Paterson in a radio interview on Monday qualified his recent criticism of U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara’s tactics, calling the hard-charging prosecutor “fantastic” when it comes to pursuing public corruption.

But at the same time, Paterson criticized Bharara on Fred Dicker’s Talk-1300 radio show for his public comments critical of Albany writ large.

“The U.S. attorney in my opinion has been fantastic,” Paterson said in the interview this morning. “He has an excellent grasp of when to take matters forward and when not to.”

But Paterson, the state Democratic Committee chairman, reiterated his criticism of Bharara, first made on a Binghamton radio station last week.

Paterson noted he’s not the only one to criticize Bharara: A federal judge knocked the prosecutor for public comments made after the arrest of Assemblyman Sheldon Silver on corruption charges, saying they walk “up against the line” of appropriate.

Bharara has criticized what he sees as a culture of pervasive corruption in Albany as well as the so-called “three-men-in-a-room” style of budget negotiations.

“Some of his comments were beyond the pale,” Paterson said. “The way government works is something prosecutors always seem to want to talk about but they’ve never seemed to be in these positions.”

Paterson added: “I think the prosecutors play to the media sometimes.”

Paterson’s comments come as Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos has confirmed he’s cooperating with a federal investigation being conducted by Bhararas office.

The former governor, who led the Senate Democrats as minority leader before running on Eliot Spitzer’s gubernatorial ticket, called the Skelos news “sad.”

A factor in the investigation is Glenwood Management. The New York Times reported last week the company itself is not under investigation, but its longtime principle is Leonard Litwin, a prolific campaign donor.

Paterson praised Litwin as a “gentleman” and “one of the best dressed men you’ll ever meet.”

He also decried the amount of money in politics, which he said has an impact on politicians.

“When people give you a lot of money and they call you on the phone and you’re not listening more clearly than usual, I think you’re kidding yourself,” Paterson said. “You tend to react to people who are filling your campaign coffers.”

Paterson’s own tenure as governor ran afoul of ethics violations, including the acceptance of complimentary Yankees tickets. But Paterson questioned some public corruption cases in general for their level of severity.

“All I’m saying just so people understand — there are crimes, they’re easy to understand, I think some of these charges are so complicated that it’s hard to figure out if they’re crimes or ethics violations that the person should be punished, but not put behind bars,” Paterson said.

Republicans Pounce On Cuba Trip

From the Morning Memo:

The New York State Republican Committee on Monday plans to staunchly criticize Gov. Andrew Cuomo for taking a state delegation of business representatives and lawmakers to Cuba.

In a statement to be released later this morning, the GOP committee is turning to its finance chairman, Arcadio Casillas, whose family left Cuba after falling victim to the Castro regime.

“Years ago, my father was murdered by the Castros and I risked my life to escape,” Casillas says in the statement. “People continue to do so today. To give this regime legitimacy is counterproductive to the global cause of advancing human rights and human dignity and does not belong on the agenda of any governor or elected official, regardless of the insensitive, amoral and unilateral position of the White House. We urge the governor to rethink this adventure in light of his constituents and of its far-reaching negative implications.”

Casillas called the trip an “amoral disaster” that remains “a police state, political dissidents are imprisoned and tortured, and the Castro regime has suppressed Cubans and created poverty and disharmony.”

The statement underscores the tricky politics of Cuba’s trip the country as the U.S. begins to normalize relations.

Cuomo has faced previous questions about Cuba’s history of human rights abuses as well as its past discriminatory policies toward gays and lesbians.

In his own statement released on Sunday night, Cuomo acknowledged the country must change, and that by opening it as a new market can be a new start.

“Like other places around the world that the U.S. engages with, there are strong policy disagreements between us on issues like human rights,” Cuomo said. “The U.S. shift in policy recognizes that engagement is far more likely to lead to change in policies we disagree with. Our trade mission is part of that new engagement. New York has proudly long been a leader on issues of equality and human rights and I agree with the President that engagement is the best way to promote democracy and bring about positive change, rather than continuing a failed policy of isolation.”

Cuomo is bringing a contingent of business representatives from New York-based companies, including Jet Blue, MasterCard, Chobani and Pfizer.

A trio of Democratic lawmakers are also set to go: Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, Senate Minority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins and Senate IDC Leader Jeff Klein.

Republican Senate Majority Leader Dean Skelos, the state’s highest elected Republican, is not joining the delegation on the trade mission.

The Cuba trip is one several trade missions Cuomo is planning in his second term, with trips also planned for Israel, Japan and Mexico.