Paladino Calls Maziarz ‘Poster Child For Term Limits’

Several Western New York Republicans have come to the defense of retiring New York State Senator George Maziarz in recent days; former GOP Gubernatorial Candidate Carl Paladino is not one of them.

“I think George is probably a poster child for term limits,” Paladino said. 

Maziarz has served in the Niagara County based 62nd state senate seat for two decades.  It’s a tenure Paladino believes was too long.

“After a while they start to feel like a king, you know King George,” said Paladino. 

It’s a characterization the Buffalo businessman has repeated over the years, and one that now appears to be gaining traction.  At about the same time Maziarz announced his retirement, reports surfaced the U.S. Attorney’s Office was looking into his campaign spending.

What started as a Moreland Commission report that showed $140,000 in unspecified campaign expenditures continues to expand.  The Albany Times Union reported Friday Federal investigators are now examining unitemized checks that were made out to cash, but never reported to the state board of elections.

The latest questions center on funds from the Maziarz campaign account that were reportedly given to a youth softball team and thousands of dollars in purchases from a WNY business.  Maziarz Campaign Treasurer, Laureen Jacobs, has been asked to turn over documents but her attorney wouldn’t provide any further details.

And although charges have not been filed, Paladino isn’t giving Maziarz the benefit of the doubt. 

“In my book, he was the guy that held Niagara County down,” Paladino said. 

Paladino believes the investigation into Maziarz campaign spending is nothing compared to what he didn’t do.  That criticism has to do with what Paladino describes as more than $1 Billion from the New York State Power Authority’s budget. 

That money, according to Paladino, was generated through the sale of unused allocated power.  Money that Paladino insists should have been spent on development in Western New York.

“George turned the other way as Cuomo was sweeping the account for the last four years.  He never ensured that that money would stay here for Western New York’s benefit.  That’s the kind of stuff that bothered me about George.”

It may take some time before Maziarz’s legacy is clear.  While the jury is still out in the court of public opinion, Paladino made up his mind long ago.  

“George is going to walk away with a million, one hundred thousand dollars in his campaign account and Western New York is no further ahead today than it was when George originally took office,” Paladino added.


Gibson: ‘Common Sense, Not Common Core’

Rep. Chris Gibson may have taken a pass on running on the “Stop Common Core” ballot line being created by GOP gubernatorial candidate Rob Astorino, but he’s doubling down on his opposition to the controversial curriculum with a new web video that touts a “common sense” approach to education reform.

The video, which the Republican congressman released earlier today, is light on details. It features Jennifer Pelesz, a parent from Valatie, who touts the fact that the congressman lives locally and understands her concerns about Common Core, and Gibson’s wife, Mary Jo, who says that testing kids as a means to evaluate teachers’ performance is “not an effective way to really evaluate.”

“As a parent of three children attending our local public school, I understand firsthand the necessity of ensuring local teachers and parents have input in our education system,” Congressman Gibson said in a statement. “Washington mandates, excessive standardized testing and New York State’s implementation of Common Core have significantly hurt the education of our students. I am proud to lead efforts in the United States Congress to reduce unnecessary standardized testing and will continue to fight to increase the influence local administrators, teachers, and parents have on their child’s education.”

Common Core has been largely a state-level issue, but Gibson has been voicing opposition to the standards – and to what he believes is over-testing of public school students – for some time.

Gibson is facing a challenge from Democratic political newcomer Sean Eldridge. In the most recent fundraising quarter, Gibson out-raised his opponent, who is relying heavily on his personal wealth to fuel his campaign.

Senate Dems All In With Party-Switching Marcellino Opponent

Emboldened by the recent setbacks experienced by the Senate Republicans, the Senate Democrats are expanding their reach to support challengers to veteran incumbents previously believed to be nearly impossible to dislodge – including Long Island Sen. Carl Marcellino.

Senate Democratic Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins and DSCC Chairman Mike Gianaris will be on hand tomorrow afternoon when Sea Cliff Mayor Bruce Kennedy – a Republican who only recently joined up with the Democrats – formally kicks off his campaign against the 71-year-old Marcellino, who has held his seat since 1995.

Kennedy had been slated to challenge Democratic Assemblyman Charles Lavine – as a life-long member of the Republican Party. He was officially nominated by the Nassau County GOP (run by former state GOP Chairman Joe Mondello), and everything.

But the local Republicans pulled their support of the mayor after the Conservative Party objected to the fact that Kennedy had, in his mayoral capacity, officiated over two same-sex marriages and refused to repudiate the 2011 Marriage Equality Act (passed with the assistance of four “yes” votes from Republican senators) that made gay marriage legal in New York.

Kennedy was upset that Marcellino failed to speak out on his behalf, or even attempt to intercede with party leaders after they yanked their support for the mayor’s Assembly campaign. “I was abandoned by the party,” Kennedy told the North Word News. “Why would I want to be a part of a party that deems me unfit for obeying the law?”

Kennedy also said that his values “as they relate to human rights do not reflect views of the Nassau County Republican leadership,” and he believes elected more Democrats to the Senate would be good for Long Island residents because they “tend to be more in touch with the middle class.”

Democrats have a slight enrollment edge in the 5th SD, with 78,515 enrolled members to the GOP’s 74,250 as of April 1, according to the state Board of Elections. There are also 3,133 enrolled Conservatives, 9,917 members of the Independence Party, 731 Working Families Party members and 58,088 “blanks” who are not affiliated with any political party.

Thanks, But No Thanks

Maybe there’s something in the water that Republicans have been drinking these days, but the party’s would-be Senate candidates are dropping like flies.

Sen. George Maziarz seems to have sparked a trend by filing petition signatures to run on the GOP line in the fall and then declining the nomination at the very last minute, sending party leaders scrambling to find a replacement. No fewer than four other Republicans have done the exact same thing this week. (Monday was the deadline for accepting or declining nominations).

In at least one case, the candidate’s decision to bow out appears to be a strategic move by the Senate Republicans in hopes of finding someone stronger to run for a seat they very much need to keep – especially now that they have four empty seats to defend.

Anthony Senft, a Conservative Islip town board member who was supposed to run for the seat being vacated by Sen. Lee Zeldin as he seeks to oust Democratic Rep. Tim Bishop, announced suddenly that he has terminated his candidacy and officially declined the GOP, Conservative and Independence Party lines.

“While difficult, my family and I reached this decision over the weekend and I informed Senate Leader Dean Skelos and the local party chairmen of my decision,” Senft said in a statement released earlier today.

“…The recent criminal acts of dumping at a Town of Islip park require that I shift my focus from running a senate campaign and direct my leadership and energy into the complete remediation and redevelopment of our park. As a Councilman for the Town of Islip I, along with my fellow Town Board Members, will continue to work for the constituents including working to repair the damage caused by those who have committed environmental crimes in our community. I will help ensure the perpetrators are brought to justice.”

The dumping scandal to which Senft refers was really starting to take a toll on his candidacy – especially since he’s the town board’s liaison to the parks department and his erstwhile Democratic opponent, Adrienne Esposito, is an environmental activist and has been using the issue as a rallying cry for her campaign.

According to Newsday, GOP leaders say Islip Supervisor Tom Croci, who is just back from a yearlong Navy Reserve stint in Afghanistan, is their first choice to replace Senft on the ballot.

Keep in mind: The Republicans also have to defend the seat vacated by former Sen. Chuck Fuschillo, who made a surprise announcement on New Year’s Eve that he would be departing the Senate – effective immediately – to take a lucrative post in the private sector.

Also on Long Island, another veteran member of the GOP conference, Sen. Carl Marcellino, is suddenly facing a challenge from Sea Cliff Mayor Bruce Kennedy, who has been a registered Republican for his entire adult life, but just recently received the Nassau County Democratic Committee’s nomination to run and will be switching parties.

Kennedy was supposed to be the GOP candidate for the seat held by Democratic Assemblyman Charles Lavine. But Republican leaders withdrew their support of him after Conservative Party leaders raised objections that the mayor had officiated two same sex marriages (in keeping with the law, by the way) and refusing to endorse repeal of the 2011 Marriage Equality Act. Kennedy told a local newspaper that he was upset Marcellino had not spoken up in his defense and he felt “abandoned” by the party.

In nearby Queens, two Republicans declined to challenge sitting Democrats. Former NYC Council Minority Leader Tom Ognibene, who was also briefly the 2010 running mate for gubernatorial candidate Carl Paladino (until he lost the GOP primary to former Chautauqua County Executive Greg Edwards), circulated petitions to run against Democratic Sen. Joe Addabbo, but then declined the nomination.

During a brief telephone interview this afternoon, Ognibene insisted he wasn’t a mere placeholder candidate, saying he had been willing to run if the Senate GOP would have provided him with resources. But in the end, the leadership asked him to step aside in favor of an attorney named Ken Sullivan. Ognibene said he was happy to abdicate in favor of someone younger with more “energy,” saying it’s time for the “younger generation to step up.”

Also in Queens, Tim Furey, a Republican who had circulated petitions to challenge Sen. Tony Avella, declined the party’s nomination, a Queens source confirmed. Avella, of course, already has his hands full with a Democratic primary challenge from former NYC Comptroller John Liu, who has refused to drop his campaign even though the IDC – of which Avella is the newest member – has agreed to end its power-sharing deal with the GOP and re-join forces with the regular Democrats.

Further up the Hudson, the candidate Senate Republicans had hoped to run against Democratic Sen. George Latimer – PR executive Jean Maisano – filed petitions, but subsequently decided against taking the plunge. The GOP tried and failed to get some more familiar names to challenge Latimer, approaching former Yonkers Mayor and onetime US Senate candidate John Spencer and two-time, self-funding Senate candidate Bob Cohen, but neither was interested.

A Senate GOP source cautioned against reading too much into the phenomenon of candidates deciding not to take a shot at running this fall, insisting that it isn’t a chain reaction caused by the spate of bad news to hit the conference as of late – starting with the indictment of the chamber’s No. 2 Republican, Sen. Tom Libous, and gathering steam with the abrupt retirement announcement by Maziarz, whose campaign spending is under investigation by the US attorney’s office.

The Democrats, not surprisingly, say the GOP is in a tailspin, and things are only going to get worse from here. But the Republicans continue to insist this will be a strong year for them, and they are merely winnowing down their candidate list to a handful of strong contenders who can win if they have sufficient support and resources.

From Bad to Worse for Senate GOP

From today’s Morning Memo (item I):

Sen. George Maziarz’s abrupt announcement that he will not be seeking re-election this fall could not come at a worse time for the Senate GOP.

In order to re-take the majority, the Republicans must now do the following:

- Win battles for four open seats currently or previously held by Republicans – Maziarz, Greg Ball (Hudson Valley, retiring), Chuck Fuschillo (Long Island, retired) and Lee Zeldin (Long Island, running for Congress).

- Defeat at least two of the three Democratic marginals they are targeting – Sens. Cecilia Tkaczyk in the Capital Region, Terry Gipson in the Hudson Valley and Ted O’Brien in Rochester.

- Successfully defend two of their own marginals who are being targeted by the Democrats: Sens. Jack Martins (Long Island) and Mark Grisanti (Buffalo).

- Respond to any surprise dark horse races that pop up unexpectedly.

The GOP faced a difficult task before Maziarz dropped his political bomb Sunday night – especially given the IDC’s defection back to the arms of the so-called regular Democrats, and the newly-formed labor/NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio/Gov. Andrew Cuomo alliance that is all in on assisting the Democrats in their quest to take the majority.

It was bad enough that the Republicans’ second highest-ranked member – Sen. Tom Libous – was indicted on charges of lying to the FBI, making himself a target for the Democrats.

With Maziarz leaving under a cloud, the GOP’s task has become exponentially more difficult.

Speculation about the real motivation behind the Niagara County senator’s decision to decline the GOP nomination has kicked into high gear.

Regardless of Maziarz’s insistence that he is merely “just tired” and in need of a change after close to 20 years of driving back and forth to Albany, the news is being tied to the belief that the US attorney is looking into his campaign finances.

“My decision has nothing to do with any investigation,” the senator told The Buffalo News. “People always suggest things like that when someone is retiring. The U.S. attorney is looking into it. Let him look into it. I have nothing to hide.”

US Attorney Preet Bharara has taken over the unfinished investigations of Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s now-defunct Moreland Commission.

According to a May City & State report, the commission had been looking into $140,000 worth of unspecified expenditures by Maziarz’s campaign between 2008 and 2013 that went to pay for everything from a clown to rental to wine, flowers and specialty chocolates.

The rumor mill – fueled by gleeful Western New York Democrats – kicked into high gear following the resignation last week of two high-level Maziarz staffers.

Talk of subpoenas and the senator’s imminent resignation was all over town, though Maziarz himself was denying to reporters as late as Saturday that anything was afoot.

It’s expected that North Tonawanda Mayor Rob Ortt will be the preferred Republican candidate to replace Maziarz on the ballot.

We’ll surely hear more about this as the day wears on.

Maziaarz had faced a primary this September from Gia Arnold of Holley, whose campaign is largely focused on repeal of the SAFE Act. He also was facing a general election challenge from Niagara Falls attorney Johnny Destino, who lost to the senator in the 2012 GOP primary. Since then, Destino has switched his enrollment to the Democratic Party, and intended to challenge Maziarz in November on Row A.

Pataki And Former Aides Unite for Cahill

A veritable bevy of former Pataki administration members – from the former governor himself on down – will gather in Albany tomorrow night to host a fund-raiser for their onetime colleague, John Cahill, who is running for state attorney general against the Democratic incumbent, Eric Schneiderman.

The invite really does read like a “who’s who” of ex-Pataki aides, of which Cahill, of course, is one. He first served as DEC commissioner and chaired the Environmental Facilities Corp., and later moved to the second floor, where he eventually rose to the position of Pataki’s chief of staff.

Cahill and Pataki are still working together at the law firm of Chadbourne and Parke. They also co-founded the Pataki-Cahill Group, a strategic consulting firm that focuses on the economic and policy implications of domestic energy needs.

This event is taking place at The Barge down on the Corning Preserve. Tickets start at $200, with co-hosts paying $1,000. The fund-raiser is taking place just before the latest round of financial reports are due to the state Board of Elections (on July 15).

This will be the first time Cahill has filed a fundraising report, since he officially announced his candidacy in May, and whatever he has managed to raise – or failed to raise, as the case may be – will be viewed as a testament to the strength – or lack thereof – of his campaign.

As of mid-January, Schneiderman had $5.98 million on hand. Though public opinion polls have shown the majority of New Yorkers have no idea who Schneiderman is, despite the fact that he has held statewide office since 2010, he enjoys a strong double-digit lead over Cahill.

John Cahill Event at the Albany Barge by liz_benjamin6490

DeFrancisco Won’t Rule Out ‘No’ Vote on Tappan Zee Loan

Sen. John DeFrancisco, who could single handedly kill a controversial $511 million loan to help finance projects associated with the new Tappan Zee Bridge said during an interview that will air on CapTon this evening that he has not ruled out voting “no” on transaction – especially if the Cuomo administration is not forthcoming with information about how the new bridge is being financed.

“I voted ‘no’ a lot of times on various things in the Senate,” DeFrancisco told me. “I have no compunction at all about voting ‘no’ if it’s not the proper use of money or there’s not a full financing plan, because the people should know how they’re paying for this thing, not get a bill sent to them after it’s half built and say, ‘we have no choice.’ So, I’ve gotta make sure this is done right. If I got a vote, I’m gonna use it.”

The Environmental Facilities Corp. Board of Directors voted unanimously last week to approve the loan – about of which will be at 0 percent interest – despite questions raised by environmental activists and the EPA because it would come from a revolving loan fund traditionally used to pay for local governments’ clean water and sewer improvement projects.

But before the loan can be executed, it must be approved by the three-member state Public Authorities Control Board. A “no” vote by any one member of the PAC Board, which includes DeFrancisco, Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, and state Budget Director Bob Megna, would be enough to scuttle this deal.

And there is precedent of board members exercising this power on high profile projects. Before DeFrancisco, former Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno represented the Senate on the PAC Board, both he and Silver voted “no” in 2005 on the infamous West Side stadium project, effectively ending then-NYC Mayor Mike Bloomberg’s dream of luring the Olympics to the Big Apple.

Silver has not yet publicly weighed in on this loan. According to his office, the matter is under review.

I asked DeFrancisco, who chairs the powerful Senate Finance Committee, if the fact that the governor – who very much wants the Tappan Zee Bridge project to be a success – has turned his back on the Republicans would influence his vote. But the senator, a Syracuse-area lawmaker, insisted that would not be the case, saying he has been trying without success to get information about the financing of this endeavor for several months now.

“When there was a discussion about the Tappan Zee Bridge, I tried to get the executive director of the Thruway Authority to tell me how they were financing the bridge and there were no answers,” DeFrancisco said. “They were going to appoint somebody and so forth. So, that’s one thing I want to get out of that meeting when it happens is that in order to decide one component of financing, you gotta know the whole financial package.”

The PAC Board is next scheduled to meet on July 16, but DeFrancisco told me he has not yet heard whether the $511 million loan will be on the agenda. He said he hopes not, because he’ll be more likely to reject the project if his questions are not answered before the vote.

My full interview with DeFrancisco will air at 8 p.m. and 11:30 p.m.

Watch Here >>

Bill de Blasio, Boogeyman

From today’s Morning Memo:

If you can’t join ‘em, beat ‘em.

Even as they question whether the deal struck by their erstwhile power-sharing partner, IDC Leader Jeff Klein, with his former Democratic colleagues will stick, the Senate Republicans are seeking to turn Klein’s abandonment to their political advantage.

GOP senators – especially those who represent districts north and west of Albany – are warning that upstate will be forgotten if the downstate-dominated Democratic conference takes full control of the chamber.

And they’re playing up the fact that uber-liberal NYC Mayor Bill de Blasio is leading the charge to flip the Senate into Democratic hands, with Senate GOP Leader Dean Skelos even going so far as to suggest that de Blasio will become the “de facto governor” of New York if Democrats control both houses of the Legislature.

That’s a comment clearly designed to get under the skin of the actual governor, Andrew Cuomo, who has had a rocky relationship with de Blasio since the mayor took office in January.

Skelos drove his point home by saying Cuomo was being “timid” and “sold out” to the labor-backed Working Families Party – a top de Blasio ally – when he agreed to assist his fellow Democrats in their push to take back the Senate in exchange for the WFP’s endorsement.

Sen. Tom Libous, the deputy leader of the Senate GOP, and Senate Finance Chairman John DeFrancisco, made similar comments in separate interviews yesterday.

(Interestingly, and perhaps a bit off-message, DeFrancisco also defended IDC member Dave Valesky, saying he doesn’t support Onondaga County GOP Chair Tom Dadey’s threat to challenge the Syracuse Democrat this fall in retaliation for the IDC’s defection).

The anti-de Blasio/downstate vs. upstate argument is apparently a coordinated message for the Senate Republicans, who, according to Capital NY, plan to run this fall against “ultra-liberal New York City radicals” who are working to empower “illegal immigrants” and stifle business.

I’m pretty sure a good number of upstaters have no idea who Bill de Blasio is, but the “we’re your last line of defense against the liberals in NYC” argument is one they’ve certainly heard before from the Senate GOP.

It remains to be seen whether that line of reasoning resonates this time around.

IDC-Dem Deal Could Bring Valesky A GOP Challenger (Updated)

Perhaps they traded one problem for another?

The announcement yesterday of a post-election IDC-Democrat reunification in the Senate may result in fewer – or perhaps merely less strenuous – primary challenges against IDC members, but the deal could result in a GOP opponent for one member where none previously existed.

Onondaga County Chairman Tom Dadey issued a statement this morning raising “serious concerns” about the IDC-regular Democrat deal, and saying it will “will hand over the keys of state government to the New York City Democrats and the radical Working Families Party.”

“Putting liberal New York City interests back in charge of our entire state government would be a disaster for hardworking Upstate taxpayers, who would surely see their taxes go up and their state aid go down,” Dadey continued.”

As a result of this new development, Dadey said he is now exploring all options – including recruiting a Republican candidate to challenge Syracuse IDC member Dave Valesky.

Two years ago, the Onondaga County GOP gave Valesky a pass, declining to field a candidate against him.

That was a significant change from 2010, when Valesky was a top GOP target. And back in 2004, Dadey himself ran against Valesky on the Conservative and Independence Party lines.

Dadey’s presence that year on the ballot against the Republican incumbent, then-Sen. Nancy Larraine Hoffmann (a former Democrat), to whom he lost the GOP primary, split the vote on the right and created a narrow path to victory for Valesky.

The GOP was not at all happy about losing Hoffmann’s seat, and Dadey was persona non grata with former Senate Majority Leader Joe Bruno for some time.

Dadey went out of his way in his statement today to say that he personally likes Valesky, but just isn’t a fan of his politics at the moment.

Valesky had been facing a primary challenge from Syracuse Common Councilor Jean Kessner, but upon learning the news of the IDC-Democrat deal yesterday Kessner sounded prepared to end her campaign.

UPDATE: A Democratic consultant emails a good point, writing:

“The Republicans made Valesky’s district much more Democratic (in the last round of redistricting). The county chair’s threat is empty – especially since Valesky has won in his former district, which was much worse. Same for (Sen. David) Carlucci.”

In other words, the threat of primary battles was actually more potent, and if that has, in fact, been neutralized, then the IDC members have a heck of a lot less to worry about this fall.

House Ethics Committee Delays Probe Into Threat To TWC News Reporter

The House Ethics Committee has deferred its investigation into Rep. Michael Grimm’s post-State of the Union threat to a Time Warner Cable News reporter at the request of the US Justice Department.

The committee announced its decision today, saying that it had received a referral from the Office of Congressional Ethics back in April that Grimm, a Staten Island Republican, may have violated House rules – or the law – when he threatened to throw TWC News Washington reporter Michael Scotto off the balcony during an interview after President Obama’s State of the Union address.

Scotto had been inquiring about the congressman’s fundraising, which has for several years been the subject of a federal probe. Grimm abruptly walked away from Scotto, but then returned and said: “Let me be clear to you, you ever do that to me again I’ll throw you off this f—–g balcony…I’ll break you in half. Like a boy.”

Grimm, a former FBI agent and ex-Marine, has since been accused by federal prosecutors of underreporting hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of employee wages and some $1 million worth of revenue while running an Upper East Side restaurant, essentially keeping two sets of records and fraudulently lowering his federal and state taxes. He also allegedly lied while under oath while he was a member of Congress.

The congressman, who has consistently maintained his innocence, has been charged with, among other things, perjury, wire fraud, mail fraud, obstruction of justice, employment of illegal immigrants, obstructing and impeding tax laws, and conspiracy to defraud the United States.

The House Ethics Committee was asked by the Justice Department to defer consideration of Grimm’s threat to Scotto, and voted unanimously on June 18 to honor that request. At least annually, the committee will make a public statement if it continues to defer taking action on this matter.

Not long after the incident with Scotto, which made national headlines, Grimm apologized to the reporter and said he had “overreacted.” Grimm is seeking re-election despite his legal troubles. He is facing a challenge from former NYC Councilman Domenic Recchia.

House Ethics Committee statement on Rep. Michael Grimm by liz_benjamin6490